Skip to content

Preorders and Shopify subscription apps

Why a preorder product can't also be sold as a subscription, and how to let customers choose between them.

Last updated

Use this guide if a customer can’t choose between a subscription and a one-time preorder on the same product, or if your subscription app (Appstle, Recharge, Bold, Seal, and similar) seems to be blocked by the STOQ preorder button. This is a Shopify platform limitation, not a STOQ restriction: one Shopify product variant can only carry one selling plan group at a time, and both preorders (via STOQ) and subscriptions (via your subscription app) work by attaching a selling plan. When both try to claim the same variant, only one wins.

Check which purchase option mode your offer uses: Preorders in the left menu bar, Offers tab, open your offer, Customize, More settings, Advanced, Purchase option. This setting is what decides whether the conflict happens at all.

STOQ attaches a Shopify selling plan to the product for the preorder. If your subscription app also needs a selling plan on that same product, the two apps compete for the same slot, so customers can’t pick “subscribe” on a product where STOQ’s preorder selling plan is active.

STOQ manages the preorder through its storefront integration instead of a native Shopify selling plan, which frees the selling plan slot for your subscription app. Customers can then choose subscription or one-time preorder on the same product. This is the same toggle used for gift card and BXGY compatibility; see Which Shopify discounts work with preorders for the full mechanics.

What you give up by switching to this mode:

  • Partial payments. Full payment is collected at checkout only.
  • The STOQ offer-level discount. Shopify discount codes still work independently.
  • Scheduled fulfillment dates. The Scheduled status needs the purchase option, and fulfillment resets to Unfulfilled. On hold still works through STOQ’s own hold, see Hold preorders without the Shopify purchase option.

On a phone, this menu is collapsed. In the Shopify mobile app, tap the STOQ logo at the top of the screen to open it, then choose the section named below. There is no hamburger icon. See Finding the STOQ menu.

  1. Open the offer editor

    1. In the left menu bar of the STOQ app, click Preorders.
    2. Click the Offers tab, then open the offer you want to change.
    3. Click Customize to open the editor.

    The STOQ preorder admin inside Shopify, showing the Preorders page with its Overview, Products, Offers and Settings tabs and an Add new offer button, the Offers tab open and an offers table listing Preorder Winter (Copy) (Off), Preorder 47 (Scheduled, Collection 5 variants), Preorder 46 (Live) and Preorder Winter (Live, 1 variant) with Customer pays: Full, Shopify order status: Unfulfilled, Status, Products, Sales 7d and Revenue columns all showing 0; with markers: 1 on Preorders in the left STOQ menu, 2 on the Offers tab, 3 on the Preorder Winter offer row.

    The STOQ offer detail page for the Preorder Winter offer inside Shopify, with Overview and Orders tabs and More and Add products buttons, a Customize panel summarizing the preorder (Preorder when out of stock, Active now with Disable, Full payment, Unfulfilled) beside a live storefront preview of the Floral Shirt product at Rs 150.00 with a Preorder badge, Reserve now pay later option, purple Preorder! button and a Shipping: To be confirmed note, plus Customize, Issues with widget? and Hide buttons; with markers: 1 on the Customize button.

  2. Open Advanced settings

    In the settings list, click More settings, then Advanced.

    The STOQ Customize Preorder Winter editor overlay with a left settings list under a Preorder heading (Widget, Inventory Manual, Products 1 variant, Shipping, Payment Full, Status Live, Limits & terms, Countdown timer Off, Batches Beta Off) and an Advanced heading below it, a storefront preview of the Pant new product at Rs 500.00 with a Preorder badge, XS variant, Reserve now pay later, purple Preorder! button, and a Save changes button top right; with markers: 1 on More settings under the Advanced heading.

    The STOQ Customize Preorder Winter editor overlay with the Advanced section now expanded in the left list to show Markets, Advanced and POS, B2B & Bundles entries beneath a Hide link, the Preorder settings list above (Widget, Inventory, Products, Shipping, Payment Full, Status Live, Limits & terms, Countdown timer, Batches Beta), the Pant new storefront preview at Rs 500.00 with Preorder badge and purple Preorder! button, and Save changes top right; with markers: 1 on the Advanced row.

  3. Switch off the Shopify purchase option

    Under Purchase option, select Use without purchase option. A confirmation dialog lists the trade-offs above; confirm to proceed.

    The STOQ Customize Preorder Winter editor overlay showing the Advanced settings panel with a Cart section (Show payment details & savings in cart checked, Show fulfillment timeline in cart checked, Add custom cart attribute unchecked) and a Purchase option section offering two radio choices, Use Shopify purchase option (Recommended) and Use without purchase option which is selected, plus a Currency & custom styles CSS field below, beside the Pant new storefront preview at Rs 500.00; with markers: 1 on the Use without purchase option radio, 2 on the Save changes button.

  4. Save changes

    Click Save changes at the top right of the editor.

Add the product to your cart as a subscription (through your subscription app) and as a one-time preorder (through STOQ’s preorder button), and confirm both checkout paths complete without one blocking the other.

Why does the preorder button block my subscription app in the first place?

Both preorders and subscriptions are Shopify selling plans, and Shopify only allows one selling plan group per product variant at a time. It’s a platform-wide limit, not something either app controls.

Will my STOQ preorder discount still work in this mode?

No. The offer-level discount depends on the Shopify purchase option. Shopify discount codes still apply normally; only the discount configured inside the STOQ offer stops working. See Which Shopify discounts work with preorders.

Can I still schedule or hold fulfillment for these preorders?

You can still hold them, through STOQ’s own fulfillment hold rather than the Shopify selling-plan hold, see Hold preorders without the Shopify purchase option. Scheduled fulfillment dates, though, need the purchase option and aren’t available in this mode.

Was this page helpful?

Still stuck? Ask Quinn or chat with support